I know that when I see it again, I will be even more of a mess after "Being Alive". In general, I react to any performer showing any kind of emotion onstage, whether it be crying, a shaky voice, sniffling, wiping their eyes, anything. It always triggers a similar reaction from myself, no matter what.
Eventually, I react the same way to the same moment in any show no matter how many times I see it. My emotions are just invested completely in that single moment of the performance. For instance, I can still watch the PBS performance of "The Light in the Piazza" and sob from the last verse of "Love to Me" to the very end of the show. With Piazza, it's the beautiful happy ending, but with Robert in Company, it's - like you said - his story that stirs my emotions.
I can't imagine how emotional Raul must've been in the show after the Times interview. I only wish I could've witnessed it.
Alright, I think I've filled my quota of Raul gushing for the evening.

Time for bed!
"The world is a better place because of hairspray." - Michael Ball