2007 Leading Actor in a Musical Tony Nominee Contenders — Page 2

Seeing as his show is not a one man show, and there is original music, could Martin Short's show be a contender in musical and acting categories, thus putting Short neck and neck w/Raul?

---

Definetely Gavin Lee

I agree that the Spamalot category split was weird, but I suppose that since it was such a big commercial show, promoting as many celebrities as possible as leads was a good opportunity to better chances for a win.

I think if Raul's competition includes a lot of celebrity, (DHP and Martin Short, namely) that's going to make it a bit more interesting. The fact that he is young may not work in his favor, because he'll have many more chances, even if the consensus does end up being regarding Bobby as the performance of his career. So I agree with the idea that while it could be looked at as an award for good work over a long period of time and that that could be a big factor, it could work the other way because he's only what, thirty-six?

Well, I'll keep my fingers crossed. I think he does outstanding work.

---

Updated On: 11/19/06 at 01:32 PM

But Michael Arden should just get a Tony for being so gosh darn adorable! If he gets nominated I will laugh. Just like how I laugehd at the Wedding Singer.
I want Alexander Gemignani to win a Tony. His performance was so amazing, and as the playbill says, he looks strong enough to lift the barricades.

---

"Just last year, hardly anyone thought Christian Hoff was going to win"

Who are you referring to? I think the Tony voters thought differently.

If you are basing your thoughts on BWW's fanbase, then you are not really looking at the entire theatre community, who really did love Jersey Boys.

Most people/critics predicted Jim Dale would win in the Best Featured Actor category last year, Hoff was a surprise.

"Who are you referring to? I think the Tony voters thought differently."

Wow. You think so?

As LuvtheEmcee and FoscasBohemianDream seem to have understood with no problem, what I wrote was in no way a slam on Hoff or Jersey Boys. It is simply a fact that few if any of the major pundits, and not many posters on the various theatre boards, predicted Hoff as the winner. And my point was that the voters obviously did. I in no way implied that he didn't deserve to win. I didn't see enough of last season's nominees to even have an opinion.

Sorry that I misinterpreted you. I was thinking mostly of the various theatre pundits' predictions and the poll in the Times of supposedly knowledgeable people, which did tend to go to Dale.

I really think that Will Chase can get a Tony nomination. His performance in High Fidelity is amazing, and I think he's the best part (next to the sets) of the musical. I will be very upset if he doesn't get a nomination.

I really think that Martin Short can get nominated, and possibly win. I think this Tony "race" is going to be amazing this year, with very talented actors nominated.

Updated On: 11/19/06 at 07:26 PM

From all the bad buzz associated with High Fidelity , it'd be a surprise if Will Chase got a nomination. My money and hopes are on David Hyde Pierce who provides one of the funniest and enthusiastic performances I have ever seen on the stage in Curtains .

Will Chase is nothing short of phenomenal in High Fidelity. If he doesn't get a nomination, then I'll lose my last shred of interest in the TONYS.

---

All this speculation is a bit early but not toatlly out of line because a lot of the shows coming in have been seen Out of town or Off Broadway.

What no one has mentioned is the politics of the awards.
Michael Cervaris is well liked in the Theare world and if his show is any good he is certainly a force to be reckoned with and after losing to that little falsetto guy last year, he certainly has a sympathy effect going on (not that his talent needs it).

I can't see MARTIN SHORT... being a "special event" because of the size of the cast, original music and book. And Martin too is very well liked, so don't count him out.

Gavin Lee got amazing revues and is the real deal as far as Musical Comedy Triple Threats go, so he too can't be counted out.

Esparza will certainly get a nomination, Bobby is a difficult role to sing and act and He certainly has the talent to spare.
On the other hand, he is not the most liked performer on Broadway.
His unprofessionalism on Taboo (not that I blame him) and his lack of interest during CHITTY do not bode well for him.
if Talent was all he would be hard to beat, but...

The actor with everthing going for him is Hyde Pierce, loaded with talent, well known, well liked, "all the gifts"

But surprises are always fun too and there could be someone out there in a show we don't know about or even mentioned for Braodway this season.

If THE TIMES.. had a longer run and been better received, Arden would certainly be a contender (His time will definitely come)
Will Chase is also great but the show looks to disapoint so he is an outsider at this point.

I think the young actor from SPRING AWAKENING, Jonathon Groff would be fun to see in this category.
And the Actor who will play Starbuck in 110 (I don't know his name, shame on me)could also have a chance.

I almost forgot, D'Arcy James is no sloutch either.

All in All a terrific race is starting to heat up.

Updated On: 11/20/06 at 11:46 PM