I remember being intrigued by the film as a kid but don't remember anything else beyond "Tomorrow" and fireworks at the end.
So, basically, I know next to nothing about this musical. I do have a fuzzy memory of taking my older bro's LP copy of the OBC recording out of its plastic slip and opening it to look at the pictures. I remember really liking the designs.
I must admit, that as someone who doesn't know the musical very well at all, it's very easy to reach the end of this thread rolling your eyes. At the same time, I have to remind myself it's likely because I can't relate and not because of anything being said.
BUT....I also know it can't ALL just be me, and the thought did occur to me that there is a LOT of roadblocks being imposed that are making this one role unnecessarily and unjustifiably deep and complex. Even the comedy is said to be executed in an impossibly complex manner.
Before I get barked at, I'm not calling anyone a liar. Not doubting Loudon's brilliance, which is clearly evident in the short clips posted above. Not calling anyone's idea of what makes a good Hannigan a good Hannigan baloney. They should know more than me, anyway.
But reading all these thoughts on the mystery, magic, and complexity of good performances of this character, I'd be ****ting my pants right now if I were cast in a major Broadway revival of the musical, and in that role.
Much of that being the result of not knowing if that quality being spoken about is even reachable. And if it isn't, what if it turns out it was that way because it wasn't ever really there? Meaning, people mixing in their thoughts on brilliance and performing along with nostalgia is always a reason to be wary. On the other hand, some people can't deny there was something special there and take the risk of coming off as a "purist" or nostalgia-driven romanticizer, all so they could share what the performer did for the character, the show, for their appreciation of the art form, and for Broadway. I can certainly relate to that.
Although, I feel I must ask, is Hannigan really that well written of a role? or did Ms. Loudon expand a flimsy role with her special brand of performance magic? So far, it appears it's the latter.
And how on earth do you pronounce "LOUDON"? LOL. I know, I should know as a Broadway fan. But every now and then, even the seasoned find themselves feeling quite ignorant. :S
Recreation of original John Cameron orchestration to "On My Own" by yours truly. Click player below to hear.
