I rushed on Wednesday 5/27 (2 show day); got on line at 8:05 and there was one person in front of me who got there at 8. By 10, the line wrapped around and there were probably 35-40 people on line. I believe they have 28 tickets for each performance; the first two seats on the left and right balcony inside aisles (so, seats 2 & 4 or 1 & 3). I received Balcony row F seats 1 and 3. As others have said, they do indeed seat from the back of the balcony to the front, as the person in front of me on line was sitting behind me and the person behind me on line was sitting in front of me!
I didn't think the seats were great, but they definitely weren't as horrible as everyone is making them out to be, especially since they're only $32. High up? Absolutely. Obstructed because of the lip? Sort of, but not much happens there anyway! The real obstruction is that everyone leans forward so you're forced to do the same in order to see. Once you manage to see through the heads though, it's a good view. Better to be up high to see the dance numbers. I really loved the show!