I saw this on Saturday and am impressed with the scope of the changes that have been made since 2012; only a handful of songs remain from that version and the story has been refocused and adjusted a great deal. Stew and Heidi's score is genuinely fantastic- this is the best "rock" score in a long time (I put rock in quotes because there's a lot of blues, R&B, gospel, and funk, as well).
While the story has been refocused, it hasn't been clarified much. In fact, while some things are clearer, others are even more confusing than they were before (the English producer character, in this incarnation, is the worst victim of this).
Its lack of coherence- including a very abrupt ending- didn't really bother me, simply because the score is so electrifying and the performers (especially Ato Blankson-Wood, who comes off as a fusion of Jimi Hendrix and Prince and is a thrilling rock star of a performer) are so damned good. It also touches on some intriguing themes (there's a song questioning why African Americans still believe in God; Joe Roy has been reconceived as a sort of opportunistic Uncle Tom who is desperate to survive).
It never really pins any of those themes down for more than a moment, and never really pins down a point as a whole. It does remind me of Hedwig, in a way- except Hedwig's thesis is so, so well-defined that even in its surreal finale it is held firmly together and cathartic. This feels like a staged concept album that has never reached the full realization of its concept, which is shocking considering there are quite a lot of book scenes. But what an album!
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
Updated On: 5/23/16 at 11:41 AM