I got back awhile ago. I don't really do reviews, so I'm just going to babble on aimlessly about stuff as I remember it, if that's ok.
To start off, I Feel Pretty and A Boy Like That/I Have a Love are entirely in Spanish. There are screens with subtitles on either side of the stage. But, as far as my (albeit limited) Spanish skills could tell, the lyrics weren't directly translated. In the Post article, Laurents said Sondheim wanted to maintain the rhyming, so in I Have a Love especially, they sacrificed the literal translation for that. Other than those two songs, the Sharks' lines in the Tonight Quintet are also in Spanish, but those aren't subtitled. I found it best to ignore the song's subtitles anyway; I know the lyrics and didn't like to have to pull my eyes off the action stage just to read them. Most of the Sharks' conversations are in Spanish, and most of that is subtitled. Basic exchanges were not subtitled, but occasionally the subtitles were late picking up, so it might still be a work in progress. During the dance at the gym, Glad Hand attempted to translate every line of his speech into Spanish and butchered it. I don't know whether it was amusing or sad when I realized most of the audience probably understood his "Spanish" moreso than the actual Spanish.
What I thought was interesting was that the translations (presumably all Lin-Manuel Miranda) weren't credited at all in the playbill. It would be one thing if it were all literal dialogue translations- Babelfish could do that- but since lyrics were altered, I thought it was odd there was no mention at all of the efforts.
Anyway, since that information alone will cause chaos, I suppose no one will pay attention to the rest of what I say.
At the beginning of the show, a DC councilman gave a speech, followed by what appeared to be a receptionist or temp or intern from the mayor's office who mumbled through a proclamation declaring it West Side Story Day in DC. Alex Bernstein came out after her and gave a speech as well, which made the mayor's gesture look all the more awkward in comparison.
Matt and Josefina were really good together. My few West Side Story experiences have had pretty lame Tony/Maria pairings (movie included), which tended to put a damper on the story. She's definitely the better singer, so I can see what the ATC poster meant by saying he was weak- in a direct comparison to her, yes, but not bad.
Karen was really great- I called three friends at intermission to gush about her performance. Anita is my favorite character, but I had no expectations about how Karen would do. America definitely got the biggest audience reaction and she also got the most applause at the curtain. She was really fun and sassy without being a caricature, so the emotional shift in the second act didn't seem as forced and out of place, just a natural progression of the character (clearly I've seen too many bad community theatre productions). And if anyone was worried about her dancing- don't be.
Curtis Holbrook was almost too good as Action. It was kind of scary at times, like he was on the verge of snapping and tearing someone's head off. As a girl, it was kind of discomforting and too real at times, heh.
I'm trying to keep this positive; there are more than enough people who tear it to shreds and I don't want to contribute to that, because I did love it. One thing that stuck out to me were some of the costumes. During the dance at the gym, it was hard to tell what time period it was supposed to be. I don't think the show has to have a set date, but some of the costumes were rather era-specific. The dresses the Jets girls wore hinted at mod, but the Sharks girls were in styles very similar to the originals. There was a Shark wearing a purple Members Only jacket and Bernardo's purple and pink suit was very Color Me Badd, but many of the Jets were in modern jeans and A-Rab is wearing this odd orange striped vest that makes him look like a circus popcorn vendor. If they wanted to make it seem "timeless", they could have picked much more neutral styles, because to me it just seemed rather disjointed.
Overall, I loved it. I will totally admit I'm biased. I've loved West Side Story since I was little, so the fact that I finally saw a professional production onstage would have been enough for me, but I really like what they've done to change it. As we've seen since this was announced, some people are going to go in hating it because of the added Spanish, but that's reflecting a much deeper issue within themselves than mere loyalty to Sondheim's lyrics. If you complain about having to press one for English, you're probably better off not seeing this production. Otherwise, I think (I hope) most people will embrace the changes. This is the same show people fell in love with, and manages to be innovative and distinctive while still keeping the orchestra in the pit.
Like a firework unexploded
Wanting life but never
knowing how
Updated On: 12/16/08 at 02:32 AM