asmith0307 said: "Sorry that you didn't like it, but I think "deluded" is a strong word there. I loved Bright Star - it reminded me of home. You didn't like it, and that's okay. Not everybody is going to like every musical. There is a Tony-nominated musical from the last few years running that I can NOT stand because I think it is sophomoric and predicable, but I don't think people are "deluded" for liking it. I just understand that they see something that I don't, not that they see something that is not there."
I'm sorry if you were offended. I specifically meant comments (paraphrasing, of course) that the show was rejected because Broadway doesn't like country music or lauding the amazing character development. I enjoyed the show. It wasn't great but it was fun. I'm not upset with anyone for liking it, I'm just skeptical of praise without criticism or casting blame where it doesn't belong. I love Doctor Zhivago but I love it knowing what's wrong with it.