Posted: 9/6/18 at 8:29pm
Posted: 9/6/18 at 8:34pm
Posted: 9/7/18 at 10:40am
starcatchers said: "“Best” is subjective, but I’ve seen all but one of them and Betsy wolfe was my favorite."
100000000% Agree!
Posted: 9/7/18 at 11:39am
Jordan Catalano said: "Nicolette. Hands down. "
I can’t wait to see her next week!
Posted: 9/7/18 at 11:50am
Kat Mcphee!!! But I’m pretty sure Dwyer will change my mind or at least be tied
Posted: 9/7/18 at 1:51pm
Posted: 9/7/18 at 3:21pm
I have seen all the Jenna’s except Stephanie and Desi and thought they were all great, but if I had to choose I’d go:
1. Katharine - it’s like Sara wrote the songs for Kat’s voice and it was effortless, and her performance for me was definitely the most nuanced, realistic and moving of all the Jenna’s I’ve seen. Also it was a really great audience the night I went.
2. Jessie - I just love Jessie’s voice and her Jenna had a lot of energy, although sometimes I think Jessie’s acting is a little OTT.
3. Sara - Sara’s voice is insanely good and it was amazing seeing her sing her own songs live and she absolutely slayed them, but I did think her acting lacked in comparison to the other Jennas
4. Betsy - A really strong performance but I’m just not a huge fan of Betsy’s voice. I mean the girl can sing but for Jenna I think the role fits a more beautiful voice, if that makes sense. I also went on a fairly quiet night so I don’t think that helped as there was a little less energy in the room
Not gonna get a chance to see Nicolette sadly.
Updated On: 9/7/18 at 03:21 PM
Posted: 9/7/18 at 3:56pm
God I feel I could vote on this every day and each time I’d have a different order. Waitress is my broadway go to show wheneverI need a pick me up, and I finallllly got to see Stephanie a couple weeks ago, so I can tick off all the Broadway Jennas woohoo! They’ve all been superb Jennas for me but ....
1. Kat McPhee 2. Sara Bareilles 3. Jessie Mueller 4. Stephanie Torns 5. Betsy Wolfe
*disclaimer* I did see Betsy with Jason Mraz as Dr P tho and I just thought his acting was so hammy that I think it threw me off my enjoyment of the whole show haha!
If we’re going for best Dr P’s I have to say I absolutely LOVED Erich Bergen! And Drew is always fab
Updated On: 9/7/18 at 03:56 PM
Posted: 9/7/18 at 5:53pm
Posted: 9/7/18 at 8:40pm
