Basically, they could have just added another $25 to the ticket price and not do that pre-sale code nonsense. That would have been fairer to everyone.
Yea, they didn't expect that response, but they intended to let backers purchase 4 tickets per pre-sale code (which was later changed to 2), so they should have just limited that pledge to like 350 right of the bat. 350 pledges isn't that many, they really could have done the simple math and anticipated the possibility of that much interest...
I know they said they try to add a second performance or have it recorded but to come up with nothing to rectify this screw-up is a little sad. Couldn't they have found a bigger venue at least? City Center or the Beacon have a considerably larger capacity and a non-Broadway theater might have also made it easier to make a second performance happen...
Really would have liked to go, oh well... Cut, Print, Moving On...