I definitely think the weather played a factor. The worst of the Nor'easter hit the area from Friday through early-mid Saturday. That would not only discourage rush and lottery goers (in some cases), but also the winds made travel quite dangerous and people could have decided just to stay home. A LOT of shows were on TDF during the storm, including many new ones (MARGARITAVILLE, THREE TALL WOMEN, CAROUSEL, etc)
Re: LOBBY HERO - If I remember correctly, 2ST is a non-profit company, and so they have not only a subscription base, but also incentives to make theatre more accessible (30 Under 30), which chips away at what could be a blockbuster in a for-profit setting. However, previews just began, there isn't much buzz at the moment, and the weather threw a wrench in things last week. I'd say the next two weeks could be more telling.
Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!!
www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm