Annie Get Your Gun recouped at the Marquis in ~7 months and ran a total of 2.5 years. Drowsy Chaperone, Damn Yankees, Tyne Daly's Gypsy, and Me and My Girl also recouped at the Marquis, I believe. Some other Marquis shows came close but likely turned a profit on the road: Millie, Evita, On Your Feet, White Christmas, etc.
You guys are talking about Tootsie like it's Home For The Holidays. Its breakeven is supposedly in the mid-$600k range, and it's been well above that during its entire run. It may be worth it to keep it open through New Years if it helps the brand of the show on the road and internationally (and to get that Thanksgiving-to-Christmas bump). Can't imagine the Nederlanders have another show dying to get into the Marquis before Xmas, and they also appear to be high-level co-producers on Tootsie.
Updated On: 8/12/19 at 11:47 PM