HeyMrMusic said: "His depiction of James Brolin makes me believe he could “play straight.”"
His caricature of Brolin was the character of Alex More (a Gay character) recreating Brolin for the purpose of the telling of this story. If you want to believe who could "play straight" - it would be Alex.
RESPECTFULLY - The complexity of Urie's extremely laudable performance (including his representations of both Streisand and Brolin, as created by the Gay character of Alex) doesn't factor into any believably regarding whether/not Urie can "play straight" in any other situation.
I truly don't mean to chide you for your comment. I just think that Urie's performance should be lauded for what it is. If you believe the representation of Brolin "worked" in this performance, then please give Urie his due.
The caricature of Brolin you saw wasn't Urie. It most definitely was the Gay character of Alex, recreating his moment with Brolin - brilliantly performed by Urie.
Can Urie handle straight characters believably? Why question it? Cast him. (so, yeah... back-handedly, I agree with you) 
Updated On: 4/20/20 at 10:33 PM