"Not known for having consistently great shows" -- ???? Oh, come now, the Roundabout has done UNBELIEVEABLE things to American musicals. You're forgetting their masterful jobs on Little Me, Threepenny Opera (granted, not American), Boys from Syracuse, One Hundred Ten in the Shade (which everyone was just DYING to see), Follies (one of their masterstrokes), and their latest butcher job, Pal Joey. How could you possibly suspect that they might not perform miracles for Bye, Bye Birdie? Tsk, tsk.
BroadwayEd