Posted: 11/21/16 at 4:31pm
Figured I've revive this and chime in, since I saw the show at the Royal Alex yesterday. I've actually been following this show since 2013 when I saw a bare-bones staged reading of it performed by the students at Sheridan College, where the show was workshopped and developed. Even back then, I was like DAMN, this is good stuff. I met composer David Hein afterwards and gushed.
Seeing it move to Broadway is incredibly moving to me... a scrappy little Canadian musical about such an unlikely subject has found so much success, so naturally I had to grab tickets to the Toronto run before it makes the move.
And wow. The show is better in every way. Every song retained from the workshop I saw has been rendered better, and every new song is a gut punch. The show moves as such a fast and furious pace that feels singular... I've never seen a show that felt quite like this one structurally. For a show to move this FAST and still maintain its clarity is a gigantic feat.
I cried a bunch. Not just teary eyes, but chest heaving sobs. And it wasn't even a specific thing that did it for me. I was just suddenly hit by the gravity of everything at once and became a wreck. And everyone in the audience around me had a similar experience. Crinkling napkins and sniffling noses in all directions.
The whole cast is fantastic, but my personal highlights were Jenn Collela's mighty performance, Chad Kimball's gorgeous vocals, Astrid Van Wieren's stoicism, and Q Smith's descent into helplessness.
I really hope this finds an audience on Broadway, because it has all of the power, affirmative humanity, and singularity of the best shows Broadway has seen in recent years.