Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Can she play that character...?

alright, i've had this crazy idea for a thread for a while now, but millie has finally given me inspiration to create it.

a majority of the actors on broadway are VERY talented. many can play any part they want. some roles we can't picture them in while others we say they would be perfect for.

now, we see people take over roles as replacement. let's look at the chains of people who have played different characters. now, suspending reality, can you imagine them playing the same roles?

here's an example:

Idina originated Elphaba. Shoshana took over. Shoshana was an understudy for Tracy Turnblad. could you imagine Idina playing Tracy? or Marissa playing Elphaba?

What if Shoshana went into Dirty Rotten Scoundrels? Sherie Renee Scott originated Amneris, Idina was a replacement in that role, and Shoshana replaced Idina (as stated before). Could you picture Shoshana playing Christine Colgate?

just think back to different people who have played the same characters and connect. it's interesting what you come up with!
::bust a move::
#2

re: Can she play that character...?

Can George Hearn play the emcee in cabaret?

He replaced Joel Grey in Wicked, and Joel was the emcee.


"Fundamentalism means never having to say 'I'm wrong.'" -- unknown
#3

re: Can she play that character...?

Can Brooke Shields play Fosca in Passion? She replaced Donna Murphy.

Can Phylicia Rashad play Mabel in Mack and Mabel. She replaced Bernadette Peters in Into the Woods.

#4

re: Can she play that character...?

Joel Grey was replaced by Ernie Sabella as Amos, so could Ernie Sabella be the wizard in Wicked? Or the emcee in Cabaret?
#6

re: Can she play that character...?

Christy Carlson Romano as Millie?



Christy played Belle, which Susan Egan originated. Susan was a replacement in Thoroughly Modern Millie.
::bust a move::
#7

re: Can she play that character...?

Side note: the answer to all of these so far is yes. These actors are working actors because they can do anything.

Can Carol Channing play Fosca?

Carol was Rosalind Russell's replacement in Wonderful Town (which Donna Murphy revived in 2003).
"Fundamentalism means never having to say 'I'm wrong.'" -- unknown
#9

re: Can she play that character...?

Adam Pascal playing Chad


Adam originated Radames, Cheyenne Jackson played him at one point, then originated Chad in All Shook Up
::bust a move::
#11

re: Can she play that character...?

Ana Gasteyer as Celie?

Saycon originated Celie in Atlanta. Saycon is the standby for Elphaba. Ana is Elphaba in Chicago.
#12

re: Can she play that character...?

Could Stubby Kaye have been in Ain't Misbehavin'?

Both he and Ken Page played Nicely Nicely Johnson.

Updated On: 11/28/05 at 01:56 PM

#13

re: Can she play that character...?

Nobert in a Speedo in Mamma Mia. David Ayers wore a speedo in Mamma Mia, and they both played Fieyro. re: Can she play that character...?

#14

re: Can she play that character...?

Here's a good one:

Brooke Shields played Rizzo in GREASE, as did Rosie O'Donnell. Brooke also played Sally Bowles in CABARET - can you see Rosie playing Sally??? : )
"Life is not measured by the number of breaths we take, but by the number of moments that take our breath away."
#15

re: Can she play that character...?

Lilias White Played Grizabella. As did Betty Buckley. Could Betty Buckley play Effie White?
#16

re: Can she play that character...?

I saw John Cameron Mitchell play Peter Pan years ago in Denver. (He was great.) Cathy Rigby also plays Peter Pan. Could she play Hedwig?

Hmmm...maybe she can.
Please visit Bitchy Waiter
#18

re: Can she play that character...?

keep it up guys, this thread is extremely entertainging. I don't really know anymore than what's already been said.

if brooke shields played fosca is passion i would jump off 4 bridges.

Updated On: 11/28/05 at 03:42 PM

#21

re: Can she play that character...?

*Tries to picture Idina Menzel as Sarah in Ragtime, Marie Christine, or Ruth in A Raisin in the Sun and Aura McDonald as Elphaba, Maureen Johnson, or Kate of Lippa's The Wild Party*

I like this thread. re: Can she play that character...?

Updated On: 11/28/05 at 05:39 PM

#22

re: Can she play that character...?

OOOOO!

Kerry Butler played Belle in BATB. So did Toni Braxton. Does this mean Toni can play Penny in Hairspray? I wont even ask if Kerry can be in Aida. LOL
"The only way we live beyond our lives is to connect and carve ourselves into the souls of those we love." -Little Fish
#23

re: Can she play that character...?

LOL @ ihearttheatre... further yet which stereotypical boybander role would he be?
#24

re: Can she play that character...?

idina menzel replaced sherie in aida. could idina play debbie in debbie does dallas? ....

jlt replaced chenoweth in wicked but could krisin have replaced jlt in urinetown OR footloose...thats a funny thought.

#25

re: Can she play that character...?

Could Anthony Rapp be in a boy band??

...Ohmygod. Don't use that kind of foul language around me. You must not use the phrases "Anthony Rapp" and "boy band" in the same sentence... *faints*

Haha, I'm kidding. But that is EXTREMELY frightening.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $71