Change of heart on particular actors?- Page 2

[NOWaWarning]

Posted: 5/10/20 at 6:35pm

I didn’t quite get the hype over Heather Headley for a long time. I just thought she was a serviceable actress who had a great voice. Then I saw her in the Color Purple and was blown away at her acting choices and how alive and charismatic she was onstage. She stole that show for me and that was a stacked cast.

[joevitus]

Posted: 5/10/20 at 7:12pm

Really a movie not a theater actor, but Gene Hackman.

I was a member of the Theater School at De Paul University when he got the Oscar nomination for Mississippi Burning, and that very morning they rushed him and Joanna Cassidy (who was making a movie with him--I'm guessing in Chicago) to the school and hastily assembled the entire conservatory student body for a Q&A with him. He was very entertaining, of course, but also wouldn't talk about "the biz" and very, very dismissive of work like Superman and The Poseidon Adventure, and clearly uncomfortable with the fact that the movies we all remembered him from were. When someone asked "Aren't they even fun?" he made a snide joke about working with a blue screen.  He wanted to talk Bonnie and Clyde and The Conversation. Now some of us surely had seen Bonnie and Clyde, which was rerun on television a lot, but there was barely a chance any of us--mostly 18-21 year olds, and young children when it came out--had yet encountered The Conversation.

I found him pretentious and dislikable, and it colored my opinion of his work for some time. But over the years, not only have I learned about his own bouts with depression, but also I realize we were as much the wrong group for him as he was the wrong speaker for us. Despite being a hugely accomplished actor, he wasn't there to give a class or to teach us about craft, and as I said, he wouldn't discuss the business side of the biz, so he really didn't have anything to give us. And we were too young to really know and appreciate the most important and challenging performances he had given. So my feelings have softened. 

The person who really had something to offer us was Johanna Cassidy. DePaul instilled so much crap in us that if you didn't go to a prestigious school, you had no hope of making it in the business, that many students were shocked a woman who admitted she had studied so little had gotten the breaks she had. Someone asked how that was possible, and she fairly (and rightly) indignantly said "I got my headshot and my agent and I pounded the pavement!" We learned something from her that day. We really didn't learn anything from Hackman. Which is not to say he has nothing to teach.

[blaxx]

Posted: 5/11/20 at 4:43pm

I thought Ben Platt was the epitome of overrated. He struggles to sing and his acting choices go from weird to awful. He comes across as smarmy and cocky, and I think he's the emperor's new clothes.

Nowadays, I still think the same. Oops, just realized this is a change of heart thread. Please move on... 😁

[theatreguy12]

Posted: 5/11/20 at 6:37pm

No change of heart on Donna Murphy here either. Phenomenal when I saw her in TKAI. Wonderful Town, great. And the most natural Dolly too. Just a super talented work horse on Broadway and always a joy.

My change of heart...Lupone. Just tired of the whole I don’t care what people think schtick. I find her irritating now. You can hide behind this just a chick with balls thing but the facade doesn’t change the fact one can still be obnoxious.

[jekslein]

Posted: 5/12/20 at 11:51am

NOWaWarning said: "I didn’t quite get the hype over Heather Headley for a long time. I just thought she was a serviceable actress who had a great voice. Then I saw her in the Color Purple and was blown away at her acting choices and how alive and charismatic she was onstage. She stole that show for me and that was a stacked cast."

I agree.

 

[AADA81]

Posted: 5/12/20 at 12:58pm

I saw Donna Murphy in 'Wonderful Town' twice and she was laugh-out-loud hilarious.  She was also the best Phyllis I've ever seen, in the Encores production of 'Follies'.  She has range and commitment and talent.  Just thought I'd share, in case anyone was interested.

I don't tend to dislike actors as a rule because I've been pleasantly surprised so many times by people I didn't expect to enjoy.  The only person who I suppose has worn a bit thin on me is Mandy Patinkin.  I've always thought he has a wonderful voice and can be a terrific actor, but he takes himself and his work so seriously that his performances can become a bit overbearing at times.  I still enjoy much of his work, though.

[joevitus]

Posted: 5/12/20 at 2:56pm

AADA81 said: "I saw Donna Murphy in 'Wonderful Town' twice and she was laugh-out-loud hilarious. She was also the best Phyllis I've ever seen, in the Encores production of 'Follies'. She has range and commitment and talent. Just thought I'd share, in case anyone was interested.

I don't tend to dislike actors as a rule because I've been pleasantly surprised so many times by people I didn't expect to enjoy. The only person whoI suppose has worna bit thin on me is Mandy Patinkin. I've always thought he has a wonderful voice and can be a terrific actor, but he takes himself and his work so seriously that his performances can become a bit overbearing at times. I still enjoy much of his work, though."

A friend really likes Murphy but was not thrilled by her Wonderful Town.