I saw the show yesterday (through the lotto) and I LOVED it. There were about 40-ish people at the lotto, so it wasn't that crowded compared to the nyc one. I'll just write random comments on each of the actors.
BILL LARKIN: He was an awesome Panch. He delivered all the sentences and definitions perfectly. His little breakdown was great too.
CRISTEN PAIGE: What a cute Olive! However, at times she did look a little old (not as youthful as Celia)...but she played and sung the role of Olive perfectly. Her "The I Love You Song" was truly heartbreaking.
LUCIA SPINA: She was one of my favorite parts of the show, even if she stole my card that Marcy Parks (Jen Sese) gave me during Pandemonium

. Her acting was dead on, and she sung the role almost exactly like her broadway counterpart.
DERRICK TRUMBLY: Played the role of Leaf Coneybear perfectly. His "I'm Not That Smart" was hilarious. His little mannerisms were great. And his transitions from Leaf to Logainne's dad were perfect.
BRAD WEINSTOCK: The best part of the show. I can see why the producers really wanted him as Chip. He was sooo cute (like you wanted to pinch his cheeks). His "M.U.E" was a big highlight.
ERIC ROEDIGER: Eric sounded A LOT like Dan Fogler. If I closed my eyes, I would think I was listening to the obcr. He was a great Barfee, except I still don't like the new look they gave him.
JEN SESE: Nothing too much to say about her Marcy Parks. But she was great. She was surprisingly heartbreaking when she said how she can't cry and ect.
CHRISTINE WERNY: Such a cute Logainne. She sounded a lot like Sarah though, but that's not a bad thing.
JAMES EARL JONES II: What a great actor. His transition from Logainne's dad to Mitch was so drastic and perfect. They also changed his look too. He now wears more of a thug outfit. He has a blue t-shirt, a denim jacket, an awesome belt buckle that says "MITCH", baggy jeans, and boots.
If you have ANY questions, just ask...since I'm not the best reviewer.
"Chicago is it's own incredible theater town right there smack down in the middle of the heartland. What a great city! I can see why Oprah likes to live there!" - Dee Hoty :-D