Dec 26-Jan 2 is one of the busiest theatre weeks of the NY year. Some shows may be sold out already. South Pacific comes to mind because it is a small theatre and a popular show.
You are so smart to want to see shows that are either already in the West End or will be soon.
Ragtime is very American in subject matter. The production is good and will probably be available.
Finian's Rainbow has a silly yet satiric book but the score is a gold mine and the show is very well done.
A Little Night Music hasn't opened for the press yet, but it is one of my favorites. Plus it has Angela Lansbury.
Next to Normal has its partisans. It cut a little close to the bone with me, but it was personal--I have a family member who is mentally ill. Many, many theatregoers praise it to the skies.
Memphis is lively and well acted and sung, but is almost done in by a weak script.
Fela is good and very loud. It helps if you like the Afro-beat sound. There is a lot of African dancing.
Present Laughter is a new production of the Noel Coward play. Who knows since performances don't start until Jan 2.
Superior Donuts is a sweet play that is well-acted but not imperative.
In The Next Room or The Vibrator Play is a comedy/romance that certainly has its moments and is well done.
Race just opened to mixed notices for the play and very good ones for the actors.
Bye, Bye Birdie which I have yet to see, did something unexpected. This here-to-fore actor-proof, audience-proof musical got as lethal a set of reviews as I have seen in many a season. The reviews were so downright hostile that I knew I had to see it. One reviewer even singled out the casting directors by name for special shame-on-you mention! I go tomorrow and I kind of can't wait.
There are also shows playing in smaller off-Broadway theatres too.
"If my life weren't funny, it would just be true. And that would be unacceptable."
--Carrie Fisher