I saw Cale Krise again this week and he was a lot better than when he first started. Back then he wasn't terrible, but he looked in over his head. Both times I saw him, though, the audience ATE HIM UP. (I've also seen Will Blum, who is a lot stronger in the role -- can't wait to see how this pans out.)
I don't know if this is actually the case, but considering Krise started around the same time as rehearsals for the national tour, I had a theory that he wasn't being given the amount of direction and attention he needed because their energies were being spent elsewhere. His performance wasn't really awful so much as it was one that looked like it came out of neglect by the creative team. But as I said, he's a LOT more comfortable in the role now.
Dramamama, where did PB Vault specify the rotation? I don't see it anywhere now, other than Blum doesn't even show up on BoM's main page anymore, but his own entry lists him as Cunningham.
"This thread reads like a series of White House memos." — Mister Matt