I was there tonight and really loved it. Parnell's text was very strong and the cast was uniformly wonderfully, but the evening was owned by John Benjamin Hickey, who took a break from running Chum Hum to give an absolutely SUPERB performance that rivaled his work in The Normal Heart. Hickey's character is selfish, angry, narcissistic, judgmental and hypocritical, but he's also vulnerable, funny, intelligent and striving to be a good husband and father. Rather than turning me against the character, the negative traits only caused him to be all too human and relatable, holding up a mirror to the audience, daring them to gaze into their own reflection in much the same way Ben and Phyllis function in Follies. Maybe that's the trick with writing a potentially "unlivable" character- make him or her so real that to hate them would be to hate yourself.
Tammy Blanchard only appeared in one short scene, basically amounting to an extended cameo, but she made a big splash and her sparring with Hickey (and his underlying hostility toward her) was very exciting. John Pankow offered excellent support as Hickey's best friend with a troubled marriage and bumpy career.
Patrick Breen is Next-Falling it with Hickey as his husband. This time the struggles aren't an age gap and religious differences, but how much gay couples may want to give in to a hetero-normative lifestyle now that marriage is legal, etc. Hickey says, "I don't feel gay anymore" at one point and his struggle to combine his gay identity in the 80's with what is expected of him now is very interesting. There's also good discussion about false horizons and unfulfilled desires as we age. They made for a believable couple and I would totally watch a tv show following their lives.
The set by John Lee Beatty makes for a perfect use of the space and Ellis' direction is top notch.
I reallg like the title, but I hope it doesn't turn people off from seeing the play. Anyone could relate to the characters and situations, but I think it will especially resonate with gay audiences.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!