I saw this last night (via TDF) and the show is pleasant enough with two talented performers, but the structure can't support the overly long run time and the orchestrations are painfully at odds with the setting. It sounds like they were trying to ape Jason Robert Brown, in particular The Last 5 Years, and it feels very wrong for the story. The lyrics aren't insulting, but they're often undistinguished.
The play is set up like Love Letters, the two characters reading and singing a one-sided letter writing affair. What makes Love Letters such a remarkable piece is that though it is set up as nothing but the reading of a correspondence between two childhood friends, Gurney does far more showing than telling and the final emotional pay off can be quite genuine. Gurney also is smart enough to keep through curveballs at the audience and smartly keeping the couple apart for most of the narrative.
Daddy Long Legs announces its premise quickly and you instantly see where it will lead. There's no surprise to be found, so especially in the second act I just kept thinking, "Get on with it!" Instead of showing us via anecdote that a character doesn't fit (or whatever the situation may be) the character simple announces it, often singing their frustrations and joys out in the most straightforward (read: dull) way possible.
The evening would be much worse if it weren't for the really lovely performances by McGinnis and Nolan. McGinnis in particular is very warm and in perfect voice. Sometimes they both err on the side of pop inflection, but I blame the score/orchestrations for these overzealous missteps.
Act one was better than act two, which contains several stops and starts that rehash the same feelings and struggles over and over again. Were this a NYMF show I would be congratulating them on a great start to having something solid. Seeing how this has been bouncing around for years I fear this is as good as it will get.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!