I don't see him as the right type either up front, but he is a character actor, so we'll see.
He'll have to do as much of a transformation as he did in "There Will Be Blood" to pull this off... changing his speaking voice, his mannerisms, his walk, everything. And he should put on a little weight for it too. A lanky, wispy Guido isn't going to cut it.
And then there's the singing. Can he or can't he?
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22