That tumblr reviewer also liked Jordan's performance, and based on his overall enthusiasm for every element of the show, one gets the feeling that he would find something to like if a canned ham played J.M. Barrie.
I'm not sure what to think of the London reviewer, although his failure to spell Kelsey Grammer's name correctly makes me think that he might be more of a blogger with no editor.
The reactions to this show remind me of other shows like Leap of Faith and Bonnie & Clyde, where people seemed to absolutely love it, or hate it with a passion. There doesn't appear to be any middle ground. When the real reviews come out, it will be interesting to see which side they fall on.