Saw this last night and I'm just kind of baffled. Like, I don't get why people are flocking to it? It doesn't really have spectacle. It doesn't really have that interesting of a story. The characters aren't particularly well drawn. I don't get it? I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it.
There was just no concept. The set was this like story-book looking set, which was rather ugly and made the whole stage feel cramped. The set pieces tracked on, but I saw actors moving most of the scenery, which made the whole thing feel slightly cheap. I just thought the whole show would have this big, expensive look to it, and it looked cheaper than Pippin. There was only one moment of real "magic' and even it felt cheap by having the actors in the dark throwing things into the light. I thought there'd be flying and all this creative, inventive direction, but it was all very straight forward.
The music was very English pop, which I don't mind, but it didn't particularly suit the story. "Stronger" is a catchy tune, but me and my friend were like "what is he stronger than?" The stakes didn't seem all that high for such an involved song with jungle drums and pirate ships. "Circus In Your Mind" and their duet in Act II were the highlights to me. But again, I felt like they were horribly staged.
Morrison was fine. He was in great voice, and he seem committed. But that accent. It wasn't bad, but it just seemed over powering and a little hokey.
Laura Michelle Kelly was just beyond to me. She was in glorious voice. I wish her big solo had been a better song, but she killed it. And her vocals throughout were pretty awesome. Just wish she was given more to do. She barely registers.
Warlow was great. He was also in great voice, and really killed the part.
The boy playing Peter was terrible. His vocals were off, and his big duet with Morrison was so awkward cause the harmonies were all out of key. The song is just too high for him. So why they would cast him I don't know. It doesn't sound good in his voice.
Overall, I'm just confused as to why this is such a hit. I mean, they cast a So You Think You Can Dance winner as Peter Pan, and she doesn't do anything. She dances for 2 minutes in the opening and then disappears. What's the point of her? We're all waiting to see Peter Pan cause they've been talking about it for 2 hrs, and then we finally see her and she's in a terribly visible harness and then that's it.
I don't get it.