Posted: 9/1/22 at 1:03pm
Merrily We Roll Along is my favorite show, and I've always been so curious as to what everyone's preferred album of the show is. The original is my favorite, I just wish the transitions were split up from other tracks. The full Haymarket album is finally on Spotify and it's a close second. Other opinions?
Posted: 9/1/22 at 1:04pm
The original. After that it’s the City Center recording with Lin and Celia.
Posted: 9/1/22 at 1:29pm
Posted: 9/1/22 at 2:09pm
TotallyEffed said: "The original. After that it’s the City Center recording with Lin and Celia."
Agreed. Tunick’s expanded orchestrations for Encores! are delightful.
Posted: 9/1/22 at 2:22pm
i also love this show, it has made me cry so many times. As for the recordings, my fav one keeps changing which I don’t know why.
Recently I listen to the York Theatre off broadway recording most of the time. But for Opening Doors and Our Time, there has been no better versions than the ones from the OBC recording, IMHO
Updated On: 9/1/22 at 02:22 PM
Posted: 9/1/22 at 2:36pm
My favourite is the Leicester/Haymarket recording. Nice cast, great orchestra, and I really like the open sound of it. A big highlight is the orchestrations in "Now You Know" with the whole: "What's your choice, count to ten..." love that bit.
Second is the OBC - fascinating, and as said above by another, "Our Time" really shines.
Posted: 9/1/22 at 2:50pm
I listen to the Encores revival recording most often. For me, it’s the recording that best captures the entire show.
Posted: 9/1/22 at 3:50pm
It has to be the OBC, all of the others have an almost clinical sound that hampers the score. The excitement, for me, really comes from the vibrant and slightly imprecise passion, which makes it feel larger-than-life in the same way that everything does when you're an adolescent - aided, of course, by the booming atmosphere of Thomas Z Shepard's audio production. A Chorus Line's 2006 revival recording had the same problem, where it went from this wild, vital sign of the times to a squeaky clean, impersonally professional period piece.
.jpg?format=auto&width=365)
