I second Bright Star- it has a great strings sound that might work beautifully. If you go with anything from Hamilton, "Burn" would be good, but I also think "Wait For It" might make a lovely program; the rhythm of the chorus would lend itself nicely to a step sequence and/or jumping passes.
Jason Robert Brown has some music that might work nicely. The Bridges of Madison County has some strong ballads, such as "Almost Real," that have an elegant build. I would stay away from Rodgers and Hammerstein unless it's a lesser-used song; nothing from The Sound of Music. Some of the music from South Pacific might work, depending on your style as a skater.
If you're a female skater with a diva-y style (a la Ashley Wagner, for instance), Evita might be an interesting choice, but NOT "Don't Cry For Me, Argentina" unless it's part of a medley. "She Used To Be Mine" from Waitress could be good, but for a more mature skater (at least mid/late teens). I would avoid show-biz musicals (Chorus Line, 42nd Street, etc.) just because they're easy to make campy and hard to make interesting.
A lot of this depends on your age and level, too; I would recommend very different musicals to a 13-year-old competing novice than a 17-year-old junior than a skater in the adult competition track. I'd be happy to chat on PM if you'd rather not disclose that sort of info on the public board :) And best of luck!!
Updated On: 12/6/16 at 05:51 PM