Still collecting my thoughts following the show, but wow what an incredible, emotional and special performance. The cast left it all on the stage. It was pretty much a flawless performance - nobody broke or did anything crazy, just some extra riffs, dance moves and lingering hugs which was great.
The crowd was also just perfect. I was worried we'd get random cheers or "woos" at inappropriate times but there was none of that. As Janet Krupin (swing) tweeted, Idina got 29 seconds of applause just for walking out on stage. There was entrance applause for the other principals as well and long ovations after every song. LaChanze and Jenn Colella were other-worldly during Love While You Can - I was left breathless which was a great setup for Always Starting Over! As others have reported, Idina choked up right before the final word and the audience got right behind her with a big cheer ... she smiled and the blew the roof off with her final note.
Great curtain call and speeches from Tom Kitt & Brian Yorkey. Idina laid a big old kiss on Yorkey after he thanked her for choosing this show when she had her choice of any role she wanted. Yorkey also spoke a lot about the courage it took for all involved in producing this show and the courage we need to keep making new musicals.
Stage door was crazy - I wouldn't trade a million autographs for the chance to have been inside that theatre. Plus I was chatting with friends outside the main entrance and had the good fortune to see both Kitt & Yorkey. I was thrilled to thank them for creating If/Then - they were super gracious and signed my playbill and did the same for others. FYI Idina did not sign autographs or go out the stage door.
I like a good rhyme more than a good time