Free Streaming of Book of Mormon Cast Album — Page 5

To reiterate what was sort of already said, neither Trey nor Matt are atheists; they just find the outlandish tale of Joseph Smith and his golden plates to be the most unbelievable of all religions. The show is totally pro-faith. Any other message in this type of show would come off as stale, unfunny, and just plain cruel.

As far as the Tony number, Kad has a point. Although "Along Came Bialy" may have seemed "messy" and "disjointed", it ISN'T a single song- it segues into a blissful Act One Finale with counterpoint and a recap of themes; this is exactly what "Man Up" does, hence why it would be an exciting showcase for every cast member as well as the score's affection for musical theatre. The problem with Tony-specific montages is that they are so often hurriedly thrown together that we barely get a solid 60 seconds of one particular song, making the whole presentation less fluid and the individual tunes less developed. And, though "Shrek" did it, I doubt they'd use "Turn It Off" since it's sung by just a featured actor. Our leads might as well order take-out and sit in the wings. "Hasa Diga" would be beyond pointless since fewer people than ever would be seeing the song uncensored due to the venue switch.

---

Is there a song without "f#ck" in it to use at the Tonys?

I suppose they could just ring a doorbell every time the word "f#ck" is sung.

This show, at least from its songs, is not "pro-faith" at all. Certainly not pro this faith. If its creators do have faith in any religion(s) it's pretty obvious they are basically saying tongue-in-cheek that their religion or faith is so much more normal or worthy than what these "stupid Mormons" rely on. It seems intellectually dishonest to pretend or claim otherwise.

The finale is pretty uplifting and pro-God. They sing "Thank you God" numerous times.

That's pretty close to the show's moral, yes.

---

Like SporkGoddess and Kad said before Parker and Stone basically believe every religion, along with Mormonism, is pretty ridiculous. Still, 'All About the Mormons?' is one of my favorite South Park episodes for giving their take on the origins of Mormonism while also showing the followers as kind people who are pretty harmless. I am getting the same vibe from listening from the recording.
Full Episode

While in an ideal world they would be able to showcase the whole cast, the main point of a performance on the Tonys is to sell tickets. They want to impress the viewers. They are going to go for their funniest number without crossing the line into offensive territory. They will save that as a surprise for when people come to see the show. They want to appeal to as wide a spectrum as possible when they perform, so I doubt they will go for Man Up or All American Prophet for that. Those numbers are funny, but not out of context. They need to make the audience laugh, and their best bets for that are Two By Two and Turn It Off.

Rufussars, I am pretty sure both Trey and Matt have self-identified as atheists, or at least agnostics who happen to find all religions absurd but their members fascinating.

I personally found Two by Two one of the least interesting songs in the show. I'm surprised so many of you would like to see it featured on the Tonys.

*Possible Spoilers*

I know a lot of folks (here and many other places) have said that Book of Mormon is pro-faith. But I'm not quite sure I agree. At the end of the show, the Ugandans have been converted to the "Book of Arnold," but it's made quite clear that they recognize that the stories are just that - metaphors to guide them through life, not literal truth.

To me, that doesn't qualify as faith. There are many fictional stories that I find inspirational (like the one under discussion!), but I know they're fiction, so this isn't a matter of faith. It seems to me that the characters' explicit recognition of the stories as fiction seriously undercuts the claim that the show is pro-faith.

Anyhow, I might be all wet about this, but it's been on my mind since I saw the show.

Updated On: 5/10/11 at 08:50 PM

For the Tony performance- yes, it is important to be entertaining and get people interested. In the case of this show, I think the producers may very well take this opportunity to pick a number that says, "Look, our show is really fun and funny- but not the level of vulgarity you'd expect." For as many people are buying, or have bought, tickets based on Trey Parker and Matt Stone's involvement, I'm sure there are people that are staying away because of it and their reputation. This would be a good place to dispel some of that.


As for the Ugandans acknowledging the stories as being metaphorical, I got the impression that the overall message being conveyed was that it didn't matter if you believed religious lore to be true or not as long as you used the messages contained therein to make yourself happy. The Ugandans thought it was metaphorical, but at the end of the show the Mormon missionaries weren't in the same boat / Elder Price is possibly atheist.

---

"Does anyone else think that Sal Tlay Ka Siti sounds JUST like another Musical Theatre song? I can't put my finger on it."

It's "Somewhere That's Green" from Little Shop.

on a side note, the show added two more swings to the cast: Valisia LeKea(u/s Nabulungi) & Douglas Lyons.

---

I hadn't thought about it, but "Making Things Up Again" does sound similar to "There is Life Outside your Apartment" and they come in the same position (Act 2 openers) in both shows.

I confess that I found some of the borrowing other melodies funny (beginning of "I Believe" right out of "I Have Confidence") but I think it verges on being a little over the top.