Saw this last night and really, really enjoyed it.
The show is in really excellent shape – much better shape than a lot of pre-Broadway tryouts, I believe. Not just in terms of production/performance quality (there were no tech issues that I noticed and everything seemed really tight – if you didn’t know ahead of time, I don’t think anyone would guess they were in their first week of previews), but in terms of the written show, as well. There were really no awkward or forced moments/scenes that I feel like are often present in these pre-Broadway tryouts as they work out the kinks. This show really flowed quite smoothly and there weren’t any moments that lagged or felt out of place. Not to say there isn’t room for improvement, but certainly nothing stood out as needing significant reworking (there are clunkier moments/scenes in many shows that are hits that have been running for years).
The songs are fine – many are quite fun and provide nice insight into the characters. “The Waters Rise” was heartbreaking. The act one finale “Swagger” song was a favorite of mine, as well.
The show is filled with a lot of laughs and I was pleasantly surprised by how clever a lot of the jokes were (I later remembered that the book is being co-written by Bob Martin, whose humor I love). Not to say the jokes are overly witty, but this is a show that could easily take a lot of cheap shots with its humor, but I was happy to find it was more than that.
The cast is great. I really enjoyed Haven Burton and Georgia Engel is perfect for her role. Nancy Ticotin is a stand-out, as well. It’s extremely easy to be charmed by everyone right off the bat.
I know a few have mentioned that they didn’t like that the younger cast members were a part of the final dance, but I actually really loved that aspect. It felt like it was everyone coming together, everyone on equal ground. I thought the final number was quite celebratory in that way.
As someone mentioned above, it is very reminiscent of “Bring it On” (which I, personally, loved). Lots of fun, a very ensemble piece, and a team to root for.
The show won’t change lives, but it does have more substance to it than other fun, light musicals of its kind. It’s hard to pinpoint, but there is a realness and groundedness to it that is really appealing. You get the feeling that in different hands, this story and presentation could have been taken too far over the top and played for easy laughs and reactions, but this feels just right. It’s not trying to be anything more than what it is – and what it is, is more than worthy. I really enjoyed myself for the entire 2 and half hours and was impressed all around.