I agree that Ellen Burstyn should have won that year. She was phenomenal in Requiem. But, for Julia, if not for that role, then WHEN? And you know she HAD to get one, too many people adore her.
I still say that Traffic was a better film than Requiem. I love them both. They are VERY different to say the least. Requiem has such a visceral, insider take on drug abuse. But Traffic was about showing the big picture. And, as in both Aranofsky films, the characters are so distraught, so tormented and sickening that I had a hard time feeling empathy as much as revulsion and sympathy. But I felt for Benicio and Michael Douglas. They felt real to me.
Requiem felt like a symphony. It was pure emotion. It's art. So's Traffic. But Traffic told a more compelling story even while not eliciting as strong of an emotional response as Requiem. That's my thought anyway.
Word. Word, indeed.