41st Street is not the same 41st Street it was when Rent opened. That theatre is now surrounded by the new New York Times building, the 42nd Street Hilton Hotel, Red Lobster, Ruby Tuesday's and a New York Sports Club, a major subway hub, boutique hotel right next door, and the New Amsterdam dumping half its audience onto that street.
The Nederlander has about 1,200 seats. The Martin Beck had about 1,200 seats when Guys & Dolls played there. (The mezzanine at the Martin Beck was extended and 200 seats were added around 1996 in anticipation of the big hit new musical, Whistle Down the Wind.)
I can tell you that pre-Rent, the Nederlander, while never a glamour pit, was a comfortable house, with good sightlines and a really good sized stage. It also doesn't have an undesirable second balcony, which is such a liability for some of the other musical houses.
With the rumor of a full scale restoration to its 1920s splendor, I see no reason why the Nederlander could not be in demand as a musical house or play house. I have to think that's exactly what is going to happen to it, if the producers of Guys & Dolls have indeed booked that house. And before you say it can't be made attractive, I would say I never thought the Longacre could ever look like it does now.
Begin at the beginning and go on till you come to the end: then stop.
Updated On: 8/28/08 at 08:14 PM