So there will be a stage version? The Variety article seems to be saying that she will do both versions.
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/19/06
I am perfectly ok with this.
I'm expecting a musical witha similar concept to Gypsy. Musical based on legend's biography...anyone else see that? And I love Hathaway...bring it on!
After seeing Rachel's Getting Married I'm excited to see Hathaway tackle this role dramatically. But, will they be using Hathaway's own singing voice? I just can't see her, or anybody else for that matter, doing justice to the Garland standards.
Although I enjoy Anne Hathaway, no one will ever be a more brilliant Garland than Judy Davis AND Tammy Blanchard. How different will this production be from Me And My Shadows?? That was such a brilliant movie.
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/19/06
^ Just like no one was ever more/as brilliant than:
Ethel Merman or Angela Lansbury in GYPSY (Patti LuPone)
Idina Menzel in WICKED (Stephanie J. Block)
Zero Mostel in FIDDLER ON THE ROOF (Topol, Harvey Fierstein)
Joel Grey in CABARET (Alan Cumming)
Ethel Merman in ANNIE GET YOUR GUN (Reba McEntire)
husk,
Elphaba = Character
Judy Garland = Person
That notwithstanding, I am excited for this. I was watching Prada last night and thought that Anne could actually play a very passable Audrey Hepburn.
Idina Menzel in WICKED (Stephanie J. Block)
My dog could have done a better job than Idina Menzel. And my dog died before Wicked opened.
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/19/06
logan-
My argument was Judy Davis and Tammy Blanchard's performances as Judy, versus Judy's performances as Judy.
I actually liked Idina...
Understudy Joined: 12/14/08
I am very excited for this. I never thought much of her as an actress, until I saw Rachel Getting Married. She was fantastic. I can't wait to see more of what she can do.
also, I hate all the Idina haters of the world. I think she was great in the role, I liked her.
I think Anne is a great choice!
I want her to play the part. I just don't want to hear her SING.
tallest Garland ever
Blanchard and Davis were dubbed in "Me & My Shadows" with Garland's own voice. I think that is the issue being discussed here. Annie H could be great - but no one can sing Garland -like Garland.
Even Angela Basset as Tina Turner was dubbed (with the real Tin'a voice) in "What's Love Got To Do with It."
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/21/06
I'm with you PJ.
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/5/04
Anne has a good voice though, doesn't she? She was in some benefit concert, I thought and most people were surprised by her voice?
Or does she just have the wrong voice for the part?
I'm afraid I don't understand this... they're making a movie AND stage adaptation? Will it be on Broadway? Before or after being in movie theaters? Anyone?
isn't she about 5 feet taller than Garland was? lol
The real Judy Garland was 4'11" 1/2... about 5'2" in heels.
Anne Hathaway is 5'8".
Judy Davis is 5'5".
Updated On: 3/24/09 at 01:24 PM
Plus--this was the bio took the low road, filled with anonymous sources claiming Judy gave blow jobs to mafiosi while singing Over the Rainbow and gargling their semen.
Lovely.
I hope this gets shelved.
The film will be based on this:
It was a hateful piece of biography-as-pathography.
Videos