I bought the Off Broadway recording before the show moved to Broadway, and frankly, I love the CD so much, it doesn't bother me that I don't have the OBCR. I loved the show so much anyway, and there are terrific songs on the CD that aren't in the show anymore. It doesn't bother me.
Dumb stories: I have practically worn out my Mamma Mia CD, and just saw the show for the fifth time. I saw it in London three years ago, and thought that was the recording I had. I discovered it's the Broadway. Sigh. I bought the CD for Mary Poppins in London the day after seeing the show for the first time. I was playing it in a CD player that I wound up returning to Target, and left the CD in there, so I had to order another one from Amazon. Dumb, dumb, dumb.
If you go on Amazon, you can generally buy these things at a discount from someone. I often order from Caiman in Florida, and have always been pleased by their service. If you wait long enough and there's a Virgin Megastore near you, they will discount the OBCR to $10. That's what I paid for Wicked in Chicago.
NYC Visitor and Broadway Fan