I was there was night too, and agree with Dave on all counts, especially about Natasha Katz nearly stealing the show with her STUNNING lighting design. The way she subtly shifted the brightness of certain scenes was very sly and smart. The end of act two had an almost Last Supper-esque tableau that she somehow made the actors look like they were glowing, yet inches away the set the set was bathed in darkness. Love her work, and the atmosphere of BAM only heightened it.
I agree that the first act is a little slow, but really it's just O'Neill slowly and carefully wiring the bomb that Hickey is going to set off in act two, and does that powder keg ever blow! The second act felt like it flew by in ten minutes and featured some thrilling acting from Lane, Dennehy and Stephen Quimette as Harry.
John Douglas Thompson's in act three was inspired- when is anything he does less than spellbinding- and of course Lane's big act four monologue must be witnessed to be believed.
Kate Arrington as Cora and Salvatore Inzerillo as Rocky were other standouts, although there wasn't a weak link in the cast.
The pacing was never sluggish and although it ran slightly over 5 hours I was never bored or fidgety once. The direction was flawless. The text brilliant. This is truly a theater lover's dream and shouldn't be missed.
I could have done without some of the audience last night though...look I realize it's a long show and one is going to get hungry, but that's what intermission is for. It's not appropriate to bust out a buffet at your seat and crinkle, crinkle, crinkle all not long. Just because your phone is on vibrate doesn't mean we all can't hear it buzzing as you refuse to answer it. Usually the hipsters at BAM just cause you to roll your eyes, but they're at least well behaved. Last night that sadly wasn't the case. Still, these annoyances couldn't hold this production down.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!