BettyBoy- When I said I didn't know why Jake would take this role I wasn't really complaining that the part is too small, but rather that the part (and play) stink.
I totally understand a star making his or her debut in supporting role, like Katie Holmes in "All My Sons." Jake just should have chosen his play much more carefully.
You what supporting role he would have been recently great for? The Tom Sadowski role in "Other Desert Cities." He would have been surrounded by excellent actors, had a few nice scenes with Stockard and then one showy monologue in act two. He definitely wouldn't have had to carry the show and his level of stardom wouldn't have seemed out of balance with the rest of the cast.
It's always disappointing when a film actor you've been excited to see on stage finally makes a debut only to find him or her in a bad role/play.
Growl- I totally agree with you with this being reminiscent of "Wild Animals You Should Know." You said everything perfectly- the dramatic scenes near the end were not earned and felt empty.
Jake's biggest mistake? Saddling himself with Roundabout. If he ever bumps into Mary Louise Parker at a party maybe they can trade war stories.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!