A lot of the songs in Ragtime do that to me, mainly the Coalhouse and Sarah ones. Some songs in Miss Saigon sound so haunting at times, they give me chills. Endless Night from Lion King. JCS has a few. Mamma Look Sharp from 1776. A couple of the ballads in Lippa's Wild Party. And some Boy From Oz songs that I can't think of the names of.
"I'm a cuber, I'm a cuber, I'm a cuber, I'm a cuber, I'm a cuber, I'm a cuber. Please don't take me to the pickle farm."- Brak