Oh man, it was fun! Like Wicked, I got in last minute and quite cheaply (I think my mezz seat was under $30) and being the shameless seat nomad I am, immediately moved up to empty seats in first row grand tier and then first row orchestra.
I think Allie and Will Swenson were my faves, but the cast was uniformly terrific, as was the orchestra. Not to mention David Pittu, who is one of our comedic treasures in recent years (And I am one of the lucky ones who did catch and love him in What's that Smell?)
I think they might even be able to transfer it to Broadway in one of the smaller houses, but if they don't, I'm especially glad I caught in at Encores.
Thanks to posters on these boards for letting me know how good it was and thanks to the folks at Encores for unearthing these gems