Saw the show Sunday, which was the 3rd preview performance. I ended the day concerned and optimistic at the same time.
In my unprofessional opinion, I am certain Constantine can be a real asset to the show. His star quality is fairly high, so that may be his biggest offering. I do think he can sing and sing well though. I would prefer he dig down and pull out an inner Anthony Warlow, which is how I describe Rob Evan's performance on the Resurrection CD. I think it is phenomenal. Constantine’s Jekyll voice is not different enough from his Hyde voice, unless he's pulling out his inner Ted Neeley at the end of Alive for example. I don't hate that choice but would much rather have the deep growl and snarl others have used.
"I Need To Know" is one of my favorite songs and have always thought it was insane to leave it out of the original Broadway production. It's made a return and is quite good, however it ends in a not so big way that I would have preferred (listen to Resurrection). Constantine’s voice appeared (only for a moment) to give out or show signs of fatigue during the prior tune, "Lost In The Darkness", but I didn't hear it again with everything that followed. It may have sounded a bit raspy at times but not fatigued (to my ears).
Overall, I liked Constantine but hope he develops both his overall singing and differences between Jekyll and Hyde. I did not find the accent bothersome and did think his overall acting was passable to good.
Deborah Cox was very good. There wasn't anything I didn't like about her and thought about earlier comments (here) that said she may have been holding back. If she was holding back, in any significant way, I would LOVE to see her play the role with it all hanging out! "A New Life" has never been a particular favorite of mine (even when Eder sings it), but I really thought Deborah nailed it and made me appreciate the song more so than ever before. My only minor criticism of her overall is there may have been a small amount of rasp in her voice, but I only detected - or thought I detected - it in very small doses.
As has been said previously, Teal Wicks is pretty awesome. I agree. Even though the role of Emma is a bit thankless, even if the 3rd (or 4th depending) biggest in the show - and gets to sing the songs I like least, Teal Wicks made a fan of me! Although also not a favorite, I REALLY wish they would add the song Emma sings in Resurrection, "If You Only Knew". The show does not have an epic running time, and Emma has so little to do. Put it in - just to get Teal Wicks some more stage time!
The rest of the cast is good to excellent. I particularly liked Jason Wooten as Stride (although the dreadlocks MUST go). As a J&H understudy, I would really like to see him perform as J&H sometime. Richard White was great, and I wish the role of Sir Danvers had more to do simply because of Mr. White's talents.
The staging was a big surprise and a plus in my book. I really held out no real hope the staging would be any good.....heck, I didn't like the Broadway staging at all (based only on videos I have seen) and had no imagination of how to do it. How would they impress me in little ol' La Mirada? From the opening curtain, I was impressed. The use of projections was not overdone, I thought, and it really added to the show.
The transformation and confrontation are highlights and much improved over previous shows (although my memory of the pre-Broadway tour says those were pretty spectacular). I sort of hope there are further refinements though. I think they can be even better. These two scenes show more of the maniac Jekyll may be and really goes into his head when he is battling Hyde. I like it.
No one has mentioned much of the orchestra - or band in this case. I was stunned to see there are so few members that make up the band. Although they do an incredible job, I really hope there is an orchestra in the future. Also, there are moments where they could dial down the volume! I love it loud, but there were times when it was just too loud. Synthesized string instruments just don't have the same impact of real ones, and turning up the volume can be too overwhelming. There are some sound effects that could be raised in volume if it were me making the decisions as well. Dialog was difficult to make out at times, both from individual singers as well as the ensemble pieces. This was likely sound engineering issues or the like more than the performer’s efforts.
I must admit that at times I felt this was a really good regional production and not something I would envision on Broadway. At other times, I thought a few small tweaks throughout the show, along with a small amount of improvement on the vocals, and this could be a really great revival and do quite well on Broadway. There are lots of performances before arriving in NYC, so I am optimistic the show will go through the changes necessary.
Updated On: 9/10/12 at 11:22 PM