macnyc said: "I saw the show Saturday afternoon, Carvajal's first performance. I agree he did very well. I have to hand it to him for stepping in like that to save the production. I think the artistic director said in her pre-curtain speech that he had been hired in Tuesday. I think he'll be up to full speed very quickly.
Hedid refer to the script much more in Act 2, but regardless I give him high marks.
I enjoyed the show a lot and look forward to seeing more of Guirgis's work at Signature. I don't know if he updated Jesus at all, since this is my first exposure to the play, but I think it is as relevant as ever.
The only drawback to the play as I see it is that it raises a lot of huge, philosophical questions but doesn't answer them. I guess it's up to us in the audience to come up with what we think.
Spoilerish question for those who have seen the play: Regarding the "nice" guard...
Click He momre To Toggle Spoiler Content...the one who brought Jenkins the cookies and was fired. He tells us at the end that he and his wife went down to Florida to show support at the execution. I thought that was so weird. He noted that Jenkins was high when he was killed. Someone else says at some point I think that the cookies contained drugs. So the nice guard was supplying inmates with drugs?
I saw the Saturday evening performance as well and thought it was very good. Props to Sean for going on with only a few days to.learn the role. As the others have said, in the second act he had to rely much more on reading the script, at one point in a key exchange with another character, he barely was able to look up from reading it. To be absolutely clear, I have no issue with Sean. Once he fully learns the role, he will be terrific. He was already really good and fully inhabiting the character. What he's done to get to that point in a few days is remarkable but his reading lessened the dramatic tension of the scene for me. Others may disagree but I believe Signature should have cancelled performances thru the weekend and given him the extra 3 days till Tuesday to get ready.
Regardless, it's a really good play and definitely worth seeing. In my mind Edi Gathegi as the other prisoner really stole the show. He was riveting in every scene he was in and his interplay with Ricardo Chavira the tough guard was fantastic.
With regard to the spoiler question, I didn't get that impression at all. It's pretty easy to score hard drugs in prison and even easier in a jail if you know who to ask. I think the nice guard just wanted to be liked by the inmates, that's all.
POSSIBLE SPOILER ALERT (Sorry having trouble using the toggle feature with my phone:
If you recall, when the tough guard found the cookies and confronted the nice guard, after the nice guard left, he ate a few so if there was something in them, he would have reacted to that. And if a prisoner is being extradited from one state to another, they are searched thoroughly. Highly unlikely anything illegal makes the trip with them. So did not get the sense at all it was anything more than regular food cause the guard wanted to be liked. Others may disagree but that's my take.