I don’t think it’s either. It’s a case of two decidedly opposite vibes.
54 Below is an uptown, supper club-type cabaret space, which caters to higher-end patrons (mostly) - which is reflected in their prices. I’m sure location is a small factor, but you also have Green Room 42 in the same vicinity.
Joe’s Pub, for my money, has always been the scrappy, downtown cabaret spot that feels accepting to artists of all stripes - alternative, raunchy, experimental, and traditional. It has the vibe of the on-campus bar I had at my college (before the renovation) - an inherent “cool” factor.
All this to say - I’m sure a show like Paulo Szot singing with the American Pops Orchestra would be just as much of an odd fit downtown, as Bridget Everett swinging her ta-tas while belting out Janis Joplin would be an odd fit at 54 Below.
Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!!
www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm