Depp is known mostly for his sly or evil or cartoonish characters.
But if you see his work in Finding Neverland, you can tell he could do the Baker justice. He just needs to approach it realistically (oddly enough). If he tries to be a crazy character, he will not only kill the role but kill the entire movie singlehandedly.
The Baker and the Baker's Wife are the heart and soul of the musical. Everybody else can be crazy ... not them.
And do we think Depp can be the sane one in a forest full of eccentric fairy-tale characters? Talk about sitting on your hands! Good luck with that, Johnny.
I'm suddenly reminded of the "fatal" casting of Daniel Day-Lewis as Guido in NINE. It threw the tone of the whole film off to have such a "weighty" actor in what should have been a lighter and more comedic role.
The difference here is that Depp CAN play this role and be the "straight guy."
But will he?
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22