VintageSnarker said: "@GavestonPS With that logic, brian is even more entitled to his opinion because he said her performance was a let down and that it underwhelmed. He didn't say anything about whether she sang well or badly. He said that he, personally, was disappointed.
"
Actually, that is not what he said in his first post on the subject. He presented his opinions as if they were facts (not "I found her underwhelming" but "she was underwhelming"
, and then announced those opinions were immune to criticism or debate.
Of course, he is entitled to his opinions. I never said otherwise. My quarrel is with the claim that his opinion is automatically immune to challenge.