Mmm, I think he'd be more likely to miscast him as Javert. Can't you see him crooning "Stars" in his Kabuki makeup? (Actually, come to think of it, he might not even be that terrible as Javert...)
PiraguaGuy, I really like some of your ideas. But Patrick Wilson's kind of, well, really old to play Marius... and I just can't see Helena Bonham Carter belting out "I Dreamed A Dream." Her voice is just too small. I wonder how Anne Hathaway would be as Fantine? As long as Zac Efron or Joe Jonas isn't Marius, I'd be fine... oh, and for some reason, I've always imagined Timothy Spall as Thenardier, just because he's so good at being disgusting!
In my pants, she has burst like the music of angels, the light of the sun! --Marius Pantsmercy