LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil- Page 3
LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
#50LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/15/11 at 12:14pmDid you not see Carol Burnett do it in Putting it Together? I'm pretty sure she was over 50 at that point.
#51LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/15/11 at 12:30pmBut Burnett didn't play Amy, she just sang the song.
#52LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/15/11 at 12:34pmI don't really see why age would matter that much. Joanne doesn't have to be the only older friend. And Marin Mazzie doesn't look old.
#53LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/15/11 at 1:14pm
I just don't see Marin as Amy at all. Ripley is more Amy, and she has played the role already.
Marin seems like a Sarah to me. Though that role would be a waste of her singing talents.
#54LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/15/11 at 1:17pm
I agree with you there. I don't see her as Amy, I just didn't understand why her age was such an issu, that's all.
I think Ripley would be a fabulous Amy!
#55LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/15/11 at 1:19pmBobby is supposed to be 35-40 and commitment-phobic, surrounded by couples. Having an Amy who is 50, marrying for the first time, and almost backing out of it completely goes against one of the central arcs of the story. Mazzie is old enough to play Joanne convincingly.
#56LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/16/11 at 12:03pmI would LOVE to hear Jason Danieley sing Sorry-Grateful
philcrosby
Broadway Legend Joined: 2/17/04
#57LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/16/11 at 12:04pm
Stritch was in her mid-40s originating Joanne. The casting in that role (as in many over the years) has crept up and up in age as our expectations of what reads as "old" has changed. LuPone is 61 or 62, and can pull off the "cougar" aspect fine. My problem with her is that she is blowsy and coarse as a performer, and Joanne (if played convincingly) comes from money and class. LuPone is also a careless and sometimes lazy singer, unless directed with an extremely strong hand.
Updated On: 1/16/11 at 12:04 PM
#58LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/16/11 at 1:13pm@philcrosby, I think Price has the strong guiding hand needed to make LuPone do her best work.
#59LuPone doing Company with the NY Phil
Posted: 1/16/11 at 1:14pm@philcrosby, I think Price has the strong guiding hand needed to make LuPone do her best work.
Videos