MYSTIC PIZZA at Paper Mill Playhouse (Reviews) — Page 2

CoffeeBreak said: "NBC ny live teaser this morning “mysticpizza jumps from the screen to the New York City stage” …."

Now this is interesting...

There is no way this is transferring, c'mon now.

Considering Krystina Alabado just joined the cast of a show in San Diego, unless they plan to recast her, I can’t imagine that they will do the transfer in time before the Tonys cutoff.

https://www.broadway.com/buzz/205235/isabelle-mccalla-krystina-alabado-kate-rockwell-and-more-to-star-in-world-premiere-of-regency-girls-at-the-old-globe/.

It’s definitely good summer fare, but the problem with shows opening between May to July is that, without MUST SEE buzz (like OH MARY or BTTF), it’s gonna ride the struggle bus - even shows under a subscription house.

ONCE UPON A ONE MORE TIME, GREY HOUSE, HOME, FRANKIE & JOHNNY, and GETTING THE BAND BACK TOGETHER are all recent examples

Mystic Pizza opens the 2026-27 Broadway series at The Clemens Center in Elmira, NY. Performances are in late September.