Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

For starters I have never even seen a clip from the original Julie Andrews film, my visit to Mary Poppins at the New Amsterdam was my first introduction to the character. In one word I found the show to be: Charming. Granted the plot, score and characters of the show are not groundbreaking in anyway but I enjoyed myself and found myself leaving the New Amsterdam with a smile and humming “Practically Perfect”.

Having never seen Julie Andrews in the role, Ashley Brown was my first Mary. I loved her in the role and only wish she could fly in when I need help. That being said I felt at times though that her character could have been stronger and exerted more of Mary’s personal strength. A perfect example of when Mary’s strength really showed was in her expulsion on Ms. Andrews in Act II. What I think endures Brown’s Mary to the audience though is her strong cheerleader in Gavin Lee who plays Bert.

Granted I wasn’t exactly wowed by his performance, I did think that he complimented Brown greatly and the two do have a great chemistry together. This really shows in Jolly Holiday and Let’s Go Fly A Kite. Rebecca Luker was great in the show; my only thought is that she is being wasted in such a small role. She did win me over as the mother. On the contrary Daniel Jenkins was good in the role of George Banks, though I thought him forgettable. Nothing from his performance really stood out.

Other than that, only one role really annoyed me and that was Janelle Ann Robinson as Mrs. Corry. Now I don’t know if the character was written like this but her accent really got on my nerves. Instead of seeming like a friend to Mary, she reminded me of that old TV psychic with a Jamaican accent that got arrested for fraud. I know this sounds politically incorrect and for that I make no apologies, to me she failed to sell her character as a woman of knowledge and mystery. Maybe someone can expand on this but for now nothing solid.

Overall I enjoyed this show and SPOLIER ALERT……

At the end when Michael hugs Mary I’ll admit, my eyes were watering. One final mention is the set, which blew me away. I felt that not only was it perfectly designed but it added to the story and the magic of the show. For that the designers deserve a round of applause.

Again if you want a fun night at the theatre go and see this show. It won’t change your world but you will leave with a smile.

Seat: Box 5
Grade: A

Quick Note: Buy the box seats, they are thirty dollars. I felt for the price you could not go wrong!
#2

re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU???

Don't even go rent the film, BUY it!!! Not only is it an Oscar-winning film, a film starring Julie Andrews and Dick Van Dyke, and not only is it a musical - but it is THE GREATEST FILM OF ALL TIME! It's timeless. And it's very different than the stage musical.
"The Spectacle has, indeed, an emotional attraction of its own, but, of all the parts, it is the least artistic, and connected least with the art of poetry. For the power of Tragedy, we may be sure, is felt even apart from representation and actors. Besides, the production of spectacular effects depends more on the art of the stage machinist than on that of the poet."
--Aristotle
#5

re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

Thanks for this review.

It piqued my interest in seeing this show more than just knowing the beauty of the original film.

How did you enjoy Cass Morgan as the Birl Woman? I'm unsure of just how small the part is, but I LOVE Cass.
#7

re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

I liked Cass Morgan but I just did not understand her role. I'm taking my mother to see on saturday, friday were at Gypsy, so I'm hoping I'll pick up more the second time around.

Oh and CapnHook, I'm doing a Mary Poppins movie night with someone who loves the film, knows the book and the musical. Don't worry got all the absses coerved.
#9

re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

I just saw the show last night and I really liked it. It's a lot of fluff but it's...well, dare I say, magical. I LOVED Gavin Lee but had lukewarm feelings about Brown.
A little swash, a bit of buckle - you'll love it more than bread.
#16

re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

Just wanted to chime in that I've never seen Mary Poppins either, so we do exist. re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

(I didn't see The Princess Bride until last year, either, hadn't seen any Little Women movie until after I saw the musical, and still have never seen Goonies...)

"This thread reads like a series of White House memos." — Mister Matt

Updated On: 7/12/07 at 12:33 AM

#18

re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

well, i hadn't seen legally blonde and mary poppins the film producion. is that a crime? besides, i avoid watching the film version of any show if its going to be a stage production. like legally blonde i didn't see the movie, but i enjoyed the stage production. i guess its a different feel from watching something live and up close rather than the tv.. i dunno thats what i think
#20

re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

JV, substitute the word of for the word on and the sentence will make sense.

I hated the stage version--I love the movie, I usually like these sort of things, I just felt my brain rotting away while I was watching it. It didn't appeal to my imagination at all. Ah well.

Elphie you're probably better off not seeing the movies in cases like Legally Blonde... which is the movie with songs added :P
yr ronin,
joey
#22

re: Mary Poppins: A Review from someone who has never seen the film

I have to say I prefer the original London production of MP to the film (that's with LMK rather than Ashley, and before they made all those hideous changes). It was less saccharine than the film, & LMK really made the character her own. Saying that I thought that ALW should never have brought SoM back to the stage (I think Connie has proved as much since...) - I think Lesley Garrett was the only improvement on the film.
Why, hello Margaret! Yes darling, half past five. Well, everyone, simply le tout Park Avenue and la creme de Hyannis! Well, the press table's going to be awfully crowded... but if you don't mind sharing a folding chair with Harper's Bazaar... Sing? Me? Heavens no, it's Edie's day, not mine... Although people can be so insistent, and I hate to disappoint. Twist my arm, blackmail me, threaten my very life, and who knows? You might get a verse of something...

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $73
Hot Show
Tickets From $89
Hot Show
Tickets From $89
Hot Show
Tickets From $65