I am familiar with many older musicals, but – having just discovered the music of “Next to Normal” and fallen in love with it – I want to find whatever else exists in terms of gorgeous contemporary Broadway music. Which musical scores do you find most beautiful/moving/goosebump-inducing? Ones you can’t imagine living without?
Miss Saigon A New Brain Parade Rent Caroline, or Change The Secret Garden Titanic Ragtime The Scarlet Pimpernel Passion Kiss of the Spider Woman Sunset Boulevard Tommy Jane Eyre Once On This Island A Christmas Carol The Light in the Piazza Billy Elliot Marie Christine The Wild Party (LaChiusa) Wicked Bombay Dreams The Pirate Queen Zorro (London) In the Heights
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
I think that the scores of "Titanic," "Side Show," "Steel Pier," and "The Dead" (unfortunately not recorded) were quite good. And I know I'm in the minority in liking "Whistle Down the Wind." (This is probably the only score of the last 20 years I actually listen to!) "Hairspray," "Spamalot," and "Altar Boyz" were also fun.
Adding to the love of Piazza, Grey Gardens, and Ragtime. It's such a shame that none of those shows won the Tonys for Best Musical in their respective years. Passion also has such a beautiful score. I have to round out my top five with Songs For a New World.
[Title of Show] Everyday Rapture (both on stage and the Cast Album, although it seems very out of place) Gypsy Les Miserables (only the actual 'named' songs. not the sung dialouge in between - I don't know the actual music term for that...aria?...just made a fool of myself sayin that! haha) Little Shop Of Horrors Sister Act - Soon-to-be-Broadway! Sweeney Todd The Producers Wicked
but my all time favourite score, ever is The Lord Of The Rings Musical, even if it is for the one song " Wonder". It did very well in the West End but i think it flopped on Broadway (didn't research that, don't quote me!)