I do not understand how people could think this show is terrible.
It is very possible that you saw a watered down, 4th rate tour - but when I saw it on Broadway with the original cast, it was one of the most electric, emotionally charged, fun, moving evenings in the theatre that I had had in a long time.
The artistry and professionalism on that stage was almost obscene. Michael Cavanaugh sounded better than Billy Joel. The new orchestrations were fantastic and a huge improvement on the originals. The story line was engaging, thought provoking, touching, and inspiring. The choreography was - while obviously not for everyone - damn good.
Even in it's final weeks on Broadway, MOVIN' OUT was still in top form and still insanely enjoyable.
What is the point of saying "It's not a musical!" It doesn't matter. The Tony Committee obviously deemed it a musical - and whether or not you believe it was - it is undeniable that it was great. Regardless of it's genre.
I cannot believe that someone would say that it's a terrible show - it's one of the best things to open so far this decade.
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy."
-Charlie Manson