I remember looking forward to this show and thinking that Tim Curry was perfectly cast, but I thought it was totally mediocre in every respect. Even Andra Martin, who I love, was only okay. She did not deserve a Tony...that category was very bad that year.
i realized from Mr. Roxy's comments that I never purchased the CD, because the score made no impression when I saw it. Made me think...the only Ahrens / Flaherty score that I have liked is Ragtime, which I think is one of the 2 or 3 best in the past 20 years. I admit that I have never listened to Once on This Island, but I thought Rocky's score, MFY's, Seussical's were all mediocre. Am forgetting what else they did right this minute.