Since on page 7 of this thread I was going into detail about my problems with the inaccuracies and misrepresentation of mental illness in NEXT TO NORMAL, I just want to point something out as to why these untruths and misinformation are so dangerous.
Some people counter my arguments by saying, "well, it's just a musical, it's not real life, it doesn't have to be incredibly accurate, it's fiction," etc.
The problem that I have is that this show is presented and marketed with a very "real" sensibility, like "this is real life," and the way it is written makes it seem very truthful.
I was just looking at the new NEXT TO NORMAL Broadway website, and the two critics' quotes on the front page read the following:
In his review of the Arena Stage production, Peter Marks of The Washington Post, wrote, "NEXT TO NORMAL is a moving,
blisteringly honest, and inordinately
powerful new musical, sung with a wallop by a six-member cast that includes the astonishing Alice Ripley, and dexterously directed by Michael Greif. Writers Tom Kitt and Brian Yorkey have stocked the musical with beautiful songs that
get to the heart of the story- and simply get to the heart." And Jayne Blanchard in The Washington Times called the show, "A transcendent production of
a powerful new American musical with a bristling, contemporary rock score,
smart lyrics and raw energy."
By selecting these quotes as a way of advertising the show, the producers, writers, and marketing team are presenting the show as "real," "honest," with "smart lyrics," a show that gets to the audience's heart.
They want their show to connect with the audience, so that people can look at what is being presented on stage as the truth, and for the audience to connect this story to their life, and perhaps reassess their situation dealing with this extremely serious, rarely explored on stage subject matter.
This is why NEXT TO NORMAL is not just simply a fictional musical.
It feels very honestly written, directed, and powerfully real, centered around a VERY SERIOUS subject matter.
So when the portrayals of mental illness being presented in the show are sensationalized pieces of misinformation, it becomes dangerous to the audience that is being told that what they are seeing on stage about the human condition is real and true.
"Winning a Tony this year is like winning Best Attendance in third grade: no one will care but the winner and their mom."
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)
Updated On: 3/11/09 at 07:46 PM